Burn it all down
Clarivate is the content-hoarding corporation that owns ProQuest, the Web of Science and EndNote, among many other services widely used in academia. Plus a ton of content. Todayâs announcement, âIntroducing ProQuest Digital Collections, a new library subscription offering unparalleled breadth, value and accessâ, sounds nice, doesnât it? And the first few paragraphs are certainly full of praise for the changes theyâre making.
Those changes amount to: libraries will no longer be able to buy books. Specifically:
Customers can continue to purchase content via perpetual archive license through December 31, 2025, after which this content will be available via subscription only.
You will only be able to rent content, not buy it.
I am quite sure this is not what the authors of books now controlled by Clarivate had in mind.
I think itâs too late for the commercial scholarly publishing sector to turn itself around â in truth it was probably already too late a decade ago, but I and others have fooled ourselves that maybe the good people at these corps can do something. They canât. Commercial scholarly publishing is owned and controlled by terminal-stage capitalists, and is consequently all about increasing the next quarterly figures â not just ignoring the needs of researchers, but even the medium- and long-term finances of the companies.
In short, the commercial scholarly publishing industry is owned by people who are quite prepared to burn it all down so long as they get rich doing it.
And I think the only response is for us to burn it down first.
The difference is, weâll replace it with something better.
doi:10.59350/qe20a-7t467