#BIBFRAME without BIBFRAME: The infrastructure of next-generation #cataloging workflows
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/07317131.2025.2512281#d1e172
#libraries #catalogs #LOD #linkeddata #Marc21 #MARC #metadata #RDF #standards
#BIBFRAME
The Linked Librar Data project at the National Library of Finland has ended and the v1.0 of the BFFI datamodel based on #BIBFRAME is now available at https://schema.finto.fi/bffi/
KB becomes [2018] the first national library to fully transition to linked data
#linkedData #Bibframe #KB #NationalLibrary #Sweden #libraries #NationalLibraries
#BIBFRAME dilemmas for #libraries: Challenges and opportunities
By Richard Wallis
https://blog.metaphacts.com/bibframe-dilemmas-for-libraries-challenges-and-opportunities
#linkeddata #LOD #metadata #semanticweb #librarycatalogs #catalogs #MARC
Programme of the 8th BIBFRAME Workshop in Europe is now available at https://2024.bfwe.eu/
Hosted by the National Library of Finland in Helsinki on September 17th and 18th.
Registration form for this hybrid event (participation is free of charge, but registration is required) and various practical information on the same page.
We welcome you to Helsinki in September in person or virtually!
#eubfws24 #bibframe @natlibfi
L'article de 2023 de Jeff Edmunds, "#BIBFRAME Must Die", soutenant que BIBFRAME n'est pas la voie à suivre pour la description bibliographique est désormais traduit en français:
"Il faut en finir avec BIBFRAME"
https://orbi.uliege.be/bitstream/2268/320486/1/Il%20faut%20en%20finir%20avec%20BIBFRAME.pdf
#MARC21 #MARC #Métadonnées #Catalogage #Catalogues #Bibliothèques #TransitionBibliographique #DonnéesLiées #WebSémantique #LinkedData #Metadata
Votre #catalogue à l'ère du web 3.0. Cataloguer aujourd'hui...
https://orbi.uliege.be/handle/2268/312552
#Catalogues #RDA #LRM #Bibframe #TransitionBibliographique #Marc #Ontologies #Webdedonnées #FRBR
@edsu At #elag2019, we already did hands-on bootcamp on creating #LOUD from the #Bibframe works dataset, indexing it and using it e.g. with #Openrefine. Slides: https://hbz.github.io/elag2019-bootcamp/ repo: https://github.com/hbz/elag2019-bootcamp I haven't heard of any new Bibframe work bulk download since, though. @thatandromeda @hochstenbach
BIBFRAME Must Die
by Jeff Edmunds
👉 October 15, 2023 marks the 21st anniversary of Roy Tennant's article "MARC Must Die." With a nod to #MARC21, this article argues that #BIBFRAME is not the way forward for bibliographic description and offers five reasons why.
https://scholarsphere.psu.edu/resources/fc19faee-70b9-44b3-9346-18e40a2cd990
BIBFRAME Must Die (by Jeff Edmunds) https://doi.org/10.26207/v18m-0g05
> October 15, 2023 marks the 21st anniversary of Roy Tennant's article "MARC Must Die." With a nod to MARC21, this article argues that BIBFRAME is not the way forward for bibliographic description and offers five reasons why.
#BIBFRAME #FRBR #RDA #Cataloging #MARC #Metadata #LinkedData #lod #Ontologies #Libraries #LoC #WorldCat #Discovery
1/2
The videos and slides from the BibFrame Workshop in Europe 2023 are available at https://www.bfwe.eu/brussels_2023
#Bibframe #cataloging #cataloguing #metadata #LinkedData #interoperability
When I was trying to debug the #LibraryOfCongress #BIBFRAME editor, MARVA, I discovered these gems in the commit log.
We are all doomed.
Problems with #BIBFRAME continued:
- It depends on a massive amount of library infrastructure and workflows that don't exist yet.
- If it ever does happen, it will rely on search engines to make catalogues discoverable in search results, which means that libraries are allowing big companies like Google to know what books you're checking out. This is a huge breach of librarians' professional ethics. (See Shayna Pekala, "Privacy and User Experience in 21st Century Library Discovery", 2017).
Gonna nerd out on library stuff here — you've been warned.
My hot take on #BIBFRAME is that it's never happening. It's been in the pipes for over ten years now, and they've done some amazing things in that time.
But:
- The cataloguing software doesn't support it.
- There are no editors (I spent all day trying to run the one made by #LibraryOfCongress and it won't go. Their readme is useless.)
Et voilà, on veut repenser le catalogue pour qu'il soit plus nativement numérique et manipulable par des machines et "dans l’ensemble, GPT est capable de cataloguer une monographie en MARC (les essais en RDA ou BibFrame ont échoué)" https://bbf.enssib.fr/tour-d-horizon/88e-congres-de-l-ifla-du-21-au-25-aout-2023-rotterdam_71424 (bon, en vrai il y a certainement des explications, comme la question des jeux d'entraînement disproportionnés, la différence entre format de notice et modèle conceptuel sous-jacent, etc.) #marc #rda #bibframe #gpt #transitionbibliographique
Réunion 2023 du Puc (Permanent UNIMARC Committee) : que devient le format #unimarc ?
La France est le seul pays à avoir fait des propositions d’évolution pour échanger des données avec le modèle #frbr puis IFLA-LRM
La tendance de fond est plutôt celle d’une sortie des formats MARC vers #bibframe vu dans nombre de pays comme le successeur du MARC
https://oubipo.abes.fr/des-nouvelles-du-puc-2023/
Getting ready to join my #ld4 Rare Materials Affinity Group colleagues for A community developed BIBFRAME profile for the description of Rare Books. The session (11am ET) will be live-streamed and recorded on LD4’s YouTube channel! #LinkedData #ld4_2023 #LD4_23 #RareBooks #bibframe
Dropping in on the Marva #BIBFRAME demo at #LD4_2023 . Enjoying the presenter walk-through; also getting a bit concerned that BIBFRAME seems still too tightly coupled to RDF than is probably good for general cataloging. (For instance, it looks from the example that author ordering has no built-in support, like it has in VIVO or Wikidata, and as a result the way creators and contributors are recorded for works seems to be clunkier than it should be)
Will someone let me know when it's time for me to understand #BIBFRAME?
Client Info
Server: https://mastodon.social
Version: 2025.04
Repository: https://github.com/cyevgeniy/lmst