#Climate (and other stuff) #Systems
brenda elthon’s short photo essay today contains a corker of a quote: (she is talking about 1968)
<<A US government scientist, speaking at a meteorology meeting, warned that burning petroleum and other organic compounds ‘to move a 120-pound woman and a bag of groceries to and from the market’ radically affects the Earth’s chemical balance and represents a long-term threat to human survival.>>
which calls to mind the observations of author john gall, who wrote about Operational Fallacies in his book General Systemantics in 1975
<<Example 1. Doesn’t the auto industry supply us with millions of new cars each year, even tailoring them to our changing tastes in style and performance?
Answer. The reason we think the auto industry is meeting our needs is that we have almost completely forgotten what we originally wanted, namely, a means of going from one place to another that would be cheap, easy, convenient, safe, and fast. We have been brainwashed into thinking that the Detroit product [cars] meets these requirements. >>
the auto industry has destroyed the face of the earth; it has dictated urban design, while the demand for oil has been behind a lot of global conflict. our economies revolve around cars. people are locked up in jails because they drove unregistered cars because they needed cars to get to work, and so on.
remember in the 1950s/1960s when suburbs all had reasonable public transport, and men (yep, blokes, mostly) still came to households delivering bread, milk, soft drink in glass bottles, collecting used glass bottles, flogging fish, sometimes rabbits, greengroceries etc?
then we got cars and started do-it-yerself shopping. thankfully, we are now reverting to some home delivery, but urban design is still a mess.
stafford beer was the bloke credited with saying The Purpose of a System is What it Does #POSIWID
<<there is "no point in claiming that the purpose of a system is to do what it constantly fails to do">> (i lifted this from wikipedia)
——-
but i digress… 1968 in the USA