#modusPonens

Nick Byrd, Ph.D.ByrdNick@nerdculture.de
2023-03-26

Why #DeepNeuralNetworks need #Logic:

Nick Shea (#UCL/#Oxford) suggests

(1) Generating novel stuff (e.g., #Dalle's art, #GPT's writing) is cool, but slow and inconsistent.

(2) Just a handful of logical inferences can be used *across* loads of situations (e.g., #modusPonens works the same way every time).

So (3) by #learning Logic, #DNNs would be able to recycle a few logical moves on a MASSIVE number of problems (rather than generate a novel solution from scratch for each one).

#CompSci #AI

Outline of Shea's talk.Two types of "representational transition" (e.g., a logical inference like modus ponens).

1. Content-specific

2. Non-content-specificWhat non-content specific transitions are useful for:
A. stuff way outside one's trained experience (e.g., learning)
B. Inferences from already stored data/memories (e.g., quickly generating novel conclusions from what you already know or identifying inconsistencies between one's beliefs to achieve reflective equilibrium).
NaraMoore ⛩️👻八尺様👻⛩️ Toot.ComNaraMoore@toot.community
2023-02-18

I feel happy
I think happy thoughts
Modus ponens

          — § —

I am sad
I think dark thoughts
Modus ponens

          — § —

Modus ponens
What a silly prompt
Silly haiku

#WOTDHaikuPrompt #ModusPonens
#Haiku #Senyru #FreeHaiku @freehaiku

2021-02-03

- implementing this function just shows that the type ((a -> b), a) -> b is #inhabited. Therefore #modusponens is true in our logic.

2021-02-02

- Function application in the #lambda calculus is expressed by β-reduction.

The Curry–Howard correspondence relates function application to the logical rule of #modusponens
Eval : morphism
Currying : isomophism

2021-01-09

- Besides atoms like numbers and strings, the only way to form new terms in #Lisp is using #modusponens

Client Info

Server: https://mastodon.social
Version: 2025.07
Repository: https://github.com/cyevgeniy/lmst