#NationOfSanctuary

Swansea Council reaffirms City of Sanctuary status in social cohesion vote

Council votes for sanctuary and cohesion

At last night’s full council meeting, councillors supported a Notice of Motion on social cohesion, with only two votes against. The motion reaffirmed Swansea’s commitment as a City of Sanctuary, supporting asylum seekers and refugees, and directly addressed recent controversy around claims made about Seaview School’s religious education classes.

The vote saw Labour, Liberal Democrat and Conservative councillors united, with senior Tory councillor Lyndon Jones backing the motion alongside his group. Reform councillor Francesca O’Brien, who represents Mumbles, opposed the motion, along with one independent councillor.

Reform voices opposition

Cllr Francesca O’Brien, elected as a Conservative in 2022 before joining Reform UK earlier this year, said she voted against because she wanted to represent “working families in Swansea” concerned about illegal immigration.

“It’s clear that this Council believes if you want to put an end to illegal immigration, you’re a racist. I’m proud to give a voice to people across my ward and across the whole of Swansea who think our laws matter, our borders matter, and our safety matters.”

A Reform UK Wales spokesperson added:

“The Tories have left the playing field on illegal immigration. The only party left that’s talking sense on these issues is Reform UK.”

Conservative backing contrasts with Senedd stance

Swansea’s Conservative councillors supported the motion, despite their Senedd leader Darren Millar previously opposing the Welsh Government’s “Nation of Sanctuary” policy. Locally, the group aligned with Labour and Liberal Democrat colleagues to reaffirm Swansea’s sanctuary status.

Council responds to Seaview School controversy

The motion followed weeks of tension around Seaview Primary School, after claims circulated online about its religious education classes. Swansea Bay News previously reported how the Council issued a formal rebuttal, describing the allegations as “misinformation” and stressing that the school’s teaching complied fully with the national curriculum.

Councillors said last night’s motion was designed to counter the spread of false claims and to reinforce Swansea’s commitment to community cohesion.

Campaigners hail anti‑racism stance

Local group Stand Up to Racism Swansea welcomed the vote, describing it as “a defence of the Nation of Sanctuary supporting asylum seekers and refugees.” In a statement, they said the motion was brought specifically to oppose “racist Islamophobic lies about Seaview School” and praised councillors for condemning hate.

The group reported that two members of the public gallery walked out during the debate, shouting obscenities, after councillors backed the motion.

Calls for action on social media hate

Earlier in the meeting, the Green Party’s Cllr Chris Evans asked the Leader to press the UK Government to hold social media companies accountable for failing to deal with far‑right hate and misinformation. He suggested councils should be able to join class action lawsuits to recover costs of dealing with unrest caused by online content.

Responding, Labour’s Cllr Rob Stewart the Leader of Swansea Council said he would write to the Prime Minister and the Secretary of State for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport, urging legislative measures to make platforms jointly liable with content creators. He warned that algorithms amplifying harmful content were “undermining social cohesion and placing additional strain on local services.”

Swansea’s journey as a City of Sanctuary

Swansea first declared itself a City of Sanctuary in 2010, becoming only the second city in the UK to adopt the title. The decision was rooted in a desire to make the city a place of welcome for people fleeing war and persecution, and it quickly grew into a wider movement.

Over the past 15 years, schools, faith groups, charities, and community organisations have joined together under the sanctuary banner. From English language classes to cultural festivals, the aim has been to weave hospitality and inclusion into everyday life. Supporters say the designation has helped Swansea build a reputation for compassion, while also challenging prejudice and misinformation.

By reaffirming its sanctuary status last night, councillors sought to restate those values in the face of recent controversy, reminding residents that Swansea’s identity as a City of Sanctuary is not just a title but a lived commitment to community and solidarity.

What it means for Swansea

The motion reaffirms Swansea’s identity as a City of Sanctuary, a designation first adopted 15 years ago. Supporters say it strengthens the city’s commitment to welcoming refugees and asylum seekers, while also sending a clear message against misinformation and hate.

Related stories from Swansea Bay News

Council hits back at misinformation on religion lessons
Swansea Council previously responded to claims about Seaview School’s religious education classes earlier this autumn.

Swansea councillor Francesca O’Brien joins Reform UK
The Mumbles councillor defected from the Conservatives to Reform UK earlier this year.

#asylumSeekers #CityOfSanctuary #FrancescaOBrien #IllegalImmigrants #misinformation #NationOfSanctuary #NoticeOfMotion #politics #ReformUK #refugees #religiousEducation #SeaviewPrimarySchool #StandUpToRacism #Swansea #SwanseaCouncil

Swansea Council Chamber inside the Grade 1 listed Guildhall
Plaid Cymru Caerffiliplaid_cymru_bgcr@toot.wales
2025-10-10

The Nation of Sanctuary does *not* mean an open door for immigration; it means help and support for the victims of war. The Nation of Sanctuary is how Wales has lived up to its values, our people doing what we can to help those who need it. The Nation of Sanctuary means children getting the support and guidance they need to recover from what they have witnessed and thrive in their new homes.

youtube.com/shorts/pxWTiaXU63I

#NationOfSanctuary #Immigration #PlaidCymru

Llanelli councillor clashes with Reform and Conservative figures over Nation of Sanctuary policy

Labour councillor Shaun Greaney said comments made by Reform’s Carmarthenshire chair Gareth Beer and former Welsh Conservative leader Andrew RT Davies calling for the policy to be scrapped were “morally indefensible”.

The Welsh Government’s Nation of Sanctuary programme was launched to support people seeking refuge, including those displaced by the war in Ukraine. Social Justice Minister Jane Hutt told the Senedd in January 2024 that more than 7,000 Ukrainians had found sanctuary in Wales, with funding used to help them move into longer‑term accommodation and integrate into communities.

At the time, Ms Hutt’s statement was welcomed across the chamber, with Conservative MS Darren Millar posting on X that his party stood “full square behind Ukraine”.

However, earlier this month Mr Davies said the £55 million scheme should be scrapped, while Mr Beer also called for its end during a BBC Wales interview.

“Hypocrisy” claim

Cllr Greaney said:

“The official record shows there was no criticism of the policy from Mr Davies or any other members of the Conservative group at the Senedd when Ms Hutt welcomed the Ukrainians and outlined the measures helping them settle here. It is hypocritical of them now to turn around and take the appalling view they have.”

He added that more than £45 million of the scheme’s cost had gone directly to supporting Ukrainian refugees, and accused opponents of “stirring things up” for political gain.

“What would they and Reform do? Turn away Ukrainians fleeing the horrors of the war inflicted upon them by Putin? Because ending the Nation of Sanctuary policy would mean just that,” he said.

Reform’s position

Reform’s Carmarthenshire chair Gareth Beer, who stood in Llanelli at the 2024 General Election, said the policy was unsustainable and unfair to local people struggling with housing and healthcare.

In a recent interview, he argued:

“If we advertise the fact that people will get free housing, free healthcare and all the rest of it, we’re basically putting up a flag to say come here when our own people can’t get housing, can’t get healthcare, and everything is at the bottom of the league tables.”

Mr Beer said Reform supported helping “genuine asylum seekers” but opposed what he described as “open‑door policies” that acted as a “pull factor” for migration.

Reform UK nationally has pledged to pursue “net zero immigration” and has made scrapping the Nation of Sanctuary one of its key policies in Wales.

Wider debate on refugees

The row comes as a new poll revealed that almost two‑thirds of people in Wales oppose plans to strip Indefinite Leave to Remain (ILR) from migrants already living here.

The survey found strong resistance to removing ILR from those who hold it, with campaigners pointing to Wales’ reliance on international workers in the NHS, care homes and universities. In Swansea Bay alone, more than 560 internationally educated nurses have been recruited in recent years to fill long‑standing vacancies.

Critics of Reform’s immigration stance say the findings show most people in Wales do not want to see families uprooted or vital staff driven away.

Welsh Government position

First Minister Eluned Morgan has defended the Nation of Sanctuary policy, saying she is “proud” Wales has “given full support to Ukraine, from the moment Ukraine was illegally and brutally invaded by Vladimir Putin”.

She said Wales had offered the “hand of friendship” to those who had lost their homes as a result of Russian aggression.

Conservative response

While Conservatives initially welcomed the policy, some members have since questioned its cost. Last week Mr Millar asked the First Minister to “scrap the wasteful policy and put the people of Wales first”.

The Welsh Conservatives and Reform UK have both argued that the money could be better spent on domestic priorities, though they continue to express support for Ukraine in principle.

Related articles

#AndrewRTDaviesMS #asylumSeekers #CllrShaunGreaney #GarethBeer #ILR #immigration #IndefiniteLeaveToRemain #LlanelliTownCouncil #NationOfSanctuary #netZeroImmigration #ReformUK #Ukraine #WelshConservatives #WelshGovernment #WelshLabour

A combined image showing Labour councillor Shaun Greaney and Reform UK’s Gareth Beer, reflecting their opposing views on the Welsh Government’s Nation of Sanctuary refugee policy.
2024-08-09

The Welsh Refugee Coalition is looking for a new Chair

Important role, especially in these times.

#RefugeesWelcomeHere #Wales #Nationofsanctuary

wrc.wales/welsh-refugee-coalit

2022-12-04

Dr Lucie Warren on the bird place:
“If you can, do give to the wonderful Birth Partner Project.
*The Birth Partner Project*
@birthproject
Shwmae! We still have a long way to go to reach our #BigGive fundraising target! Please help us by spreading the word. Donate by following this link bit.ly/3g0Vanq so more women like Christianah have their voices heard! Diolch! #maternalhealth #NationofSanctuary

2022-12-01

‘Shwmae! We still have a long way to go to reach our #BigGive fundraising target! Please help us by spreading the word. Donate by following this link bit.ly/3g0Vanq so more women like Christianah have their voices heard! Diolch!’
#maternalhealth #NationofSanctuary donate.thebiggive.org.uk/campa

Client Info

Server: https://mastodon.social
Version: 2025.07
Repository: https://github.com/cyevgeniy/lmst