Sentynelâs and Twelveâs Top Ten(ish) of 2025
By Steel Druhm
Sentynel
Itâs been a couple of years since I had to start my AotY thoughts with âoof, what a year,â but oof, what a year. One thing after another piled up for months on end. I had some early success, actually writing reviews, but that left me almost no time to consume any other new music. A slowly escalating personal crisis then led to my neither writing nor consuming any new music for months. I began to fear that I genuinely wouldnât be able to listen to enough to assemble a listâor that the server would implode at an inopportune time and Iâd struggle to fix it. Fortunately, I was able to stay on top of server wobbles, despite the best efforts of endless AI scraper bots.1 A couple of months ago, I started managing new music again, and thus, a list emerged. I am moderately optimistic for 2026, at least on a personal level. (I offer no such optimism for the general state of the world.)
While this hasnât been a particularly strong year for me, itâs hard to tell if thatâs the yearâs fault or just mine. My most common gripe has been unevenness: there have been a lot of recordsâincluding some Iâve ultimately lovedâthat have annoyed me through failing to sustain their heights throughout. Nonetheless, everything on my list belongs there. This yearâs primary theme appears to be Angry Cello Guy, with a suspicious five entries on my list prominently featuring cellos or other bowed string instruments. Guitars are so 2024. There are multiple records here that are genre-hopping, experimental, and hard to classify. Otherwise, this is a pretty typical year for me, with post-metal heavily represented, several prog-adjacent pieces, and no surprisingly brvtal contenders, despite trying a few. Ah, well, next year.
My year has also kept me from getting to know this yearâs intake of new writers as well as Iâd like, but Iâm sure theyâre all lovely people with only somewhat questionable taste. To the brave crew of editors and promo jockeys, you have my thanks for your endless work; to the retiring veterans, please enjoy your sabbaticals without incident; and to the readers, long may you continue resisting the urge to let AI summarise our writing.
#ish. Scardust // Souls â Souls took a lot longer to grow on me than Strangers, and itâs more uneven than its predecessor. But the highs are fabulous. Noa Gruman is still preternaturally good on vocals. If the whole record were as good as the âTouch of Lifeâ suite with her and Ross Jennings, this would be, no exaggeration, #1. Alas, while there are a couple of other bangers (âUnreachableâ), much of the rest of Souls just doesnât impress me, in that awkward sort of way you get when itâs really good and it feels unfair to moan about it too much, but you know they can do so much better.
#10. Jo Quail // Notan â Quail remains one of the most mesmerising live acts Iâve ever seen. Between the strength of her modern classical compositions and the frankly magical way she weaves them together live, armed with only a cello and a loop pedal, her shows are a must-see event. Fittingly, I saw Notan performed live before I heard the recording, but itâs worth it in recorded form too. The nature of loop pedal based composition lends itself to the sort of slow build that makes for really good post-rock/metal. Each piece goes in a pleasingly different direction and experiments with different additions to her sound palette. That she can do them live solo as well is merely the icing on the cake.
#9. Mares of Thrace // The Loss â I wrote most of a review for this album at release,2 but never quite got it over the line. I found it so raw it was hard to listen to. As my difficult period got worse, I just gave up on being able to listen to it at all, and with it any hope of finishing even a woefully late review. Where The Exile was immediately catchy and driving, The Lossâs immediacy is its anguish, and that was all I could hear. Mares of Thrace are already hard to genre pigeonhole, and The Loss is all over the place, spanning sludge, noise, prog, and doom, with trad inflections. Iâm actually glad I didnât manage to get the review done at the time. Coming back to it for list season, I appreciate it a lot more easily than I did at the time. The catchiness and driving energy are still there, but the additional stylistic variety makes it more interesting. The anguish adds weight and impact. The catharsis of the final track is well earned. Itâs still a hard listen, but itâs a rewarding one. Who knows, maybe Iâll even get a TYMHM out!3
#8. Black Narcissus // There Lingers One Whoâs Long Forgotten â This is just gorgeous. The best post-rock does an awful lot with very little, and Black Narcissusâ unhurried drums and bass do an absolutely astonishing amount. Thereâs no way something so minimalist and so languid should be able to sustain an hour of music. I cannot emphasise enough how absolutely beautiful There Lingers One Whoâs Long Forgotten is, and its hour-long runtime just floats by. This is the epitome of âdo one thing and do it wellâ as a philosophy.
#7. Fallujah // Xenotaph â Fallujah are a long time big name I had begun to appreciate more in the last couple of years, after seeing them live. They still hadnât really clicked for me recorded, but Xenotaph changed that. Tech deathâs curse is sterility, and the warmth of this record lifts Fallujah out of that trap. Itâs, paradoxically, at once dreamy and bluntly impactful. The writing is as strong on melody as it is on technicality. It seems slightly redundant to say this about a record thatâs on my year-end list, but I really enjoy the immediate experience of listening to Xenotaph. Thereâs something intensely satisfying about the smoothness: who says heavy music has to be abrasive? The production is still a sticking point, though.
#6. Concrete Age // Awaken the Gods â Awaken the Gods is just a lot of fun. Thereâs not enough metal drawing on the instruments and composition of folk music from the Caucasus and the steppes. It reminds me a lot of Mongol, but with better and more varied folk instrumentation. Thereâs a couple of songs that are a bit more straight thrash with folk instruments, which are less exciting, but it doesnât detract from the rest of the record. It also delivers further proof of my theory that folk metal covers of terrible pop songs are the pinnacle of music. My go-to for when I wanted something to uncomplicatedly bang my head to.
#5. Calva Louise // Edge of the Abyss â Calva Louise are what happens when somebody spots an âall of the aboveâ button under âgenreâ on the band creation screen and their curiosity gets the better of them. They are what you get if you take the Diablo Swing Orchestra and remove their classical instruments and sense of restraint. Something this absurd could only ever have been terrific or terrible. Obviously, this is terrific. AMG called it wild, unpredictable, and addictive, and it certainly is. They sound like nothing else Iâve ever listened to, and manage to be dangerously catchy on top of it. This hit in the middle of my difficult period, and it was nearly the only thing I listened to for a month. A teeny sense of easing off the gas on the last few songs is the only weakness. Spectacular.
#4. Völur & Cares // Breathless Spirit â Odd, unsettling, pretty, experimental, captivatingâBreathless Spirit is a weird album. Violin and viola occupy the sonic space where youâd typically find lead and rhythm guitars. The composition wanders through modern classical, atmoblack, noise, jazz, folk, doom, and more. Actually, the main textural comparison I would draw here is to Hierophant Violent, though Breathless Spirit is far less single-minded in direction. Many of the more ambient sections, and some of the clean vocals, remind me of the build-up stretches of that album, and likewise, thereâs some similarity in the crushing crescendos. Just in case you thought you knew where this was going, the other comparisons Iâm going to draw are to fellow Canadians The Night Watch and Thrawsunblat. Of everything on the list, this is the one at highest risk of me feeling like I placed it too low in a yearâs timeâI found it late and it could grow on me further. A truly fascinating record.
#3. Messa // The Spin â While Iâve been a fan of Messa since their first record and through all their stylistic exploration, The Spin really blew me away. Sara Bianchin sounds fantastic, and thereâs a wonderful allure to the tone of the rest of the band. Others have commented on The Spin feeling a bit like a collection of songs rather than a cohesive record, which is probably true and probably kept this from the top spot⊠but the songs are so damn good itâs hard to care that much. I came back to this a few times, even during the worst few months of the year, and had half of it stuck in my head half the time. At one point, I spent several days unable to get the opening riff of the opening track out of my head, and it doesnât get any less addictive from there. In the last couple of months, Iâve had to actively resist putting it on at times to make sure I give other, less immediate records enough listening time.
#2. Psychonaut // World Maker â Yeah, so Iâm a sucker for the kind of atmospheric post/prog metal played by bands like The Ocean or Dvne. Here is this yearâs winner in that space. Iâve wanted to like Psychonaut in the past more than I actually have, but World Maker finally clicked for me in a big way. Itâs intricate, catchy, in places techy, in others psychedelic. The songs unfold in interesting ways, and listening to it feels like exploring. From the buildup of the opening track, I knew this would be exactly what I wanted in this sort of music. And as Ken wrote in his review, the more personal dimension to World Makerâs themes elevates it (with some similarities to Pelagialâs place as the best Ocean album). A record that rewards time and attention.
#1. Shepherds of Cassini // In Thrall to Heresy â In Thrall to Heresyâs victory here was not exactly inevitable when I reviewed it back in February, but it was certainly likely. The glorious return of a niche band I loved and thought lost? It would have taken something spectacular to upset it. I listened to this all year, through the difficult period, and kept on loving it. For all that retro prog is a bit of an oxymoron, 00s-early 10s prog is one of my favorite eras of music. (There was a lot of rabbling in the comments about me not having explicitly compared them to Riverside and Tool, so to be explicit, if you liked Riverside through to SoNGS, youâll like this. Theyâre far less pretentious than Tool.) In Thrall is a fresh enough take to feel like progression, not a throwback. Its violin leads add variety (as well as claiming the Angry Cello Guy crown for the year). Shepherdsâ songwriting has matured in the last decade. Their instruments sound pleasingly chunky. A post-y twist presses additional musical buttons for me. One could only make this more laser-targeted at my specific musical niche by somehow adding industrial bluegrass.4 Donât make me wait 10 years for the next record, please.
Honorable Mentions:
- 1914 // Viribus Unitis â Brutal and moving, this is some really good blackened death/doom. Itâs not as good as Die Urkatastrophe, thoughâsorry, 1914 fans.
- Aephanemer // Utopie â The spectre of AMGâs law of diminishing recordings begins to haunt Aephanemer, for what is Utopie if not Aephanemer sounding like Aephanemer? Itâs damn good, though.
- Ellereve // Umbra â Sad-girl post-metal? Yes please.
- Howling Giant // Crucible & Ruin â Just some really good stoner/psych.
- Net-Ruiner // Prototype â The synthwave/metal cross ends up being a little too much of a gimmick to land a proper list spot, but nonetheless an absolute blast.
- Raphael Weinroth-Browne // Lifeblood â I know I made an Angry Cello Guy joke up there, but it turns out you can, in fact, have too much cello. Weinroth-Browneâs multi-layered modern classical composition (in both senses) of cellos is always impressive and regularly emotive. Had Lifeblood been edited down to keep, say, the best 40 minutes of its current 60, this would have been up there in my list somewhere. Alas.
- Various Artists // KPop Demon Hunters â Relegated to HMs because this isnât an album I like so much as itâs an album containing six songs I absolutely adore, and six others, but fuck me, the main cast songs (less âSoda Popâ) are bangers.
Songs oâ the Year:
- Calva Louise â âImpeccableâ
- Concrete Age â âBoro Boroâ
- Howling Giant â âScepter and Scytheâ
- HUNTR/X â âGoldenâ
- HUNTR/X â âTakedownâ
- HUNTR/X â âWhat It Sounds Likeâ
- Messa â âFire on the Roofâ
- Saja Boys â âYour Idolâ
- Scardust â âTouch of Lifeâ suite
- Shepherds of Cassini â âAbyssâ
- Tiktaalika â âFault Lines:
Twelve
I am so behind on writing this. Behind on writing in general, really, but Iâm writing this introduction very late by Angry Metal StandardsÂź.5 Over the year, my writing for this blog waned notably, but Iâm still very proud of my output this year, and discovered some delightful gems thanks to this blog and my privileged position to write for it. As is traditional, I want to extend my sincere thanks to my co-writers for their fantastic camaraderie and to the editors who allow me to keep writing here, probably against their better judgment. Everything changes all the time, but feeling right at home here stays the same.
Last year I claimed that, by any measure, 2024 was the worst year of my life, and Iâm happy to say that remains true this year. Interestingly, however, I listened to much less music, and, more to the point, liked less music. In the past few months, Iâve been asking my co-writers here to recommend the music they think will top their own lists, and I just⊠kept not liking them. For some reason, almost nothing has been sticking musically. Thatâs not a comment on my colleaguesâ tastes, of courseâthe writers here have an astounding talent for finding some of the best music there is. But Iâve been struggling to keep up.
So this year, Iâm keeping things simple and writing about the twelve albums I liked best in 2025. Occasionally, when we talk about our end-of-year listings, thereâs an idea that some albums need to be of a certain quality to be âworthyâ of a top-ten (or top-top) spot, but if I start thinking that way, this list is never going to materialize. So Iâve gone with my gut and am now going to talk your ear off about the music I personally liked the most.
All of which is to say, I think my list is weird this year. I did my best! And Iâm happy with it. But itâs weird.
Thanks for reading my nonsense in 2025âit really does mean a lot. Letâs all do it again next year!
#ish. Dawnwalker // The Between â A single-song album is such an ambitious undertaking, and I really canât express enough how impressive it is that âThe Betweenâ feels like an actual half-hour song. Dawnwalker is so impressive on The Between, and the composition is truly a work of art. Itâs grown on me since I reviewed it in October, and I just have to highlight the amazing songwriting from Mark Norgate and Dawnwalker before I dive into my list proper.
#10. Calva Louise // Edge of the Abyss â Let the weird begin! Edge of the Abyss is not something I thought for a second would make this list when Angry Metal Guy wrote about it, but itâs wormed its way into my head and heart. Deceptively catchy, a lot cleverer than it first appears, and filled to the brim with energy, Edge of the Abyss is a fun, memorable, and surprisingly relatable slice of⊠some kind of metal. I really donât know how to categorize it, and Iâm not sure how to get it out of my head either. Great album.
#9. Nechochwen // Spelewithiipi â Continuing with what may be another unusual pick, Nechochwenâs Spelewithiipi is not something I considered for this list straightaway. I have to admit, though, it has been a comforting listen that Iâve returned to often over the course of the year. It is well-composed, deceptively complex, and easy to spin again and again. On days Iâve felt low, thereâs been a magic in Spelewithiipi that does wonders in keeping me well.
# 8. Völur & Cares //Breathless Spirit â Breathless Spirit is such an impressive album. For one thing, youâd never, ever guess there isnât a lead guitar, despite the fact that Batesâs violin is a significant part of Völurâs unique character and spirit. As doom metal, Breathless Spirit dominates; it is powerful, mournful, wry, and cathartic. Itâs a truly fascinating display of music, one that reveals new character every time you listen.
#7. Falling Leaves // The Silence That Binds Us â Speaking of doom metal, The Silence That Binds Us tells us that sometimes taking a break can be a good thing. Itâs been thirteen years since Falling Leaves released their debut, and their sophomore feels like it had been simmering for a while. Expert compositions, passionate performances, and a huge atmosphere contribute to what I thought was âtheâ doom metal release of the year. There is so much care and attention in The Silence That Binds Us, so much feeling from every player, so much love in the production and masterâeven the cover art is gorgeous.
#6. Raphael Weinroth-Browne // Lifeblood â I didnât expect Lifeblood to creep its way up here the way it has, but Iâve been listening to it more and more lately and realized I actually like it a lot more than a lot of other stuff. Raphael Weinroth-Browneâs compositions are stunning, and the more you listen to them, the better they get. For an instrumental, non-metal project, Lifeblood conveys so much meaning, so much emotion, and feels heavy for what it is. Itâs a powerful work and a lovely one tooâexactly what weâve come to expect from as talented a cellist and composer as Weinroth-Browne.
#5. Aephanemer // Utopie â The direction Aephanemerâs music has taken since they first appeared on this blog with Prokopton is fascinating. Each release since has been a touch less aggressive and notably broader in terms of its composition and ambition. Utopie, I feel, balances these nuances the bestâitâs an epic, sprawling album that reaches high and grasps onto something exciting. There is a level of care and attention to detail to Utopie that rewards repeat listens, and I still feel like Iâm getting more and more into it as I listen. Who knows, maybe Iâll regret this âlowâ placement before long; this oneâs a grower.
#4. Amorphis // Borderlands â Amorphis donât need much introduction at this point, but lately I havenât been very invested in their releases. It can be tough, I imagine, being such an iconic band with such a recognizable sound. But Borderlands feels fresh to me; an old formula done right, modernized reasonably enough to stand out, and with the gusto of a much newer band. Incidentally, this was also the first CD Iâve purchased in yearsâan impromptu grab at a record store Iâd forgotten existedâand the bonus tracks therein are amazing additions (âRowan and the Cloudâ is a delightful closer, more so, I would argue, than âDespairâ). Itâs nice to be enamored by Amorphis again. They seem to still know what theyâre doing.
#3. Saor // Amidst the Ruins â Iâve slept on Saor in the past, but Amidst the Ruins is an amazing album. Rarely is black metalâatmospheric black metal, no lessâso impassioned, but Iâve never wanted to visit Scotland so much as the first time I heard âRebirthâ at the end of my first listen. Itâs hard to quantify what makes Amidst the Ruins such a special record, really. The blend of black metal and folk metal isnât new, nor is the style in which Marshall writes so well. But listening to Saor, you canât help but feel his pride and awe for a homeland you may never have seen yourself. Amidst the Ruins crept its way into my rotations again and again throughout the year, and itâs been the most pleasant musical surprise of 2025 for me by far.
#2. Apocalypse Orchestra // A Plague Upon Thee â I really thought Iâd give Apocalypse Orchestra my top spot, but admittedly, I thought that before Iâd even heard it. The way these guys blend medieval themes with folk, doom, and metal is genuinely fascinating and incredibly well done. Add to the list that they perform thorough research and the music is educational on top of it allâwhatâs not to love? A Plague Upon Thee was my most-anticipated album of the year, and Apocalypse Orchestra really delivered, with sweeping epics telling takes of historic darkness and endearing humanity. Everything from the bagpipes to the choirs sounds amazing, and while I did have a couple of reservations initially, the simple truth is that this music is so well up my alleyâand is performed so well tooâthat I was always bound to love it enough for this list. I can only hope to uncover more music as wonderfully niche as this again.
#1. 1914 // Viribus Unitis â I have not listened to every item of music released in 2025, but I still think I can say that none could be more powerful than 1914âs Viribus Unitis. I listened to nothing heavier, nothing more memorable, and nothing so relevant as 1914âs story of a Ukrainian soldier caught up in the mania of the First World War. From battle-frenzied bloodlust to heartbreaking captivity, his story follows 1914âs relentless message of the horrors of war. In the past, Iâve praised 1914 for the honesty in their bleak outlook on their namesake war, and Viribus Unitis could not have done a better job in following that idea. The songs range from brutal to cathartic; every guest musician elevates their song, and the choir is a brilliant way to balance trademark heaviness with emotional impact. Viribus Unitis is the most impactful album Iâve listened to in a long, long time, and I admire every musician involved for their part in that. Viribus Unitis was my top album for 2025 the moment I finished the first spin.
Honorable Mention
- Marko Hietala // Roses from the Deep â Iâve looked back at my review of Roses from the Deep a couple of times since writing and wondered if my personal admiration for Hietalaâs career made me over-excited to review it. Is it possible I rated it highly simply because itâs such a fascinating culmination of the career of a musician I like? Either way, Iâm keeping to the courseâthis was a fun listen in a year where I didnât find so many upbeat albums to enjoy, and I keep coming back to it in bits and pieces depending on my mood; itâs a diverse exploration, and you can tell everyone had a good fun creating it.
Song of the Year
This was a hard one. There are so many powerful, emotional songs littered throughout this listâespecially on Viribus Unitis, where the passion is particularly raw. But in keeping with the theme of what I personally found most affecting, I just keep coming back to this little gem on Autumn Tearsâs latest. âMartyrdom â Catharsis (Where Gods Go to Die)â has a strangely compelling quality that kept me coming back again and again since I first reviewed Crown of the Clairvoyant. The singing, choirs, organâreally, everything about the composition is mesmerizing. I donât imagine a lot of people will have this one on their year-end playlists. Itâs a niche, quiet little song, but itâs wormed its way into my heart and speaks strongly to how Iâve felt about 2025 in a way I canât quite describe.
ï»żCrown of the Clairvoyant by Autumn Tears
#1914 #2025 #Aephanemer #Amorphis #ApocalypseOrchestra #BlackNarcissus #CalvaLouise #ConcreteAge #Dawnwalker #Ellereve #FallingLeaves #Fallujah #HowlingGiant #JoQuail #Lists #MaresOfThrace #MarkoHietala #Messa #Nechochwen #NetRuiner #Psychonaut #RaphaelWeinrothBrowne #Saor #Scardust #SentynelSAndTwelveSTopTenIshOf2025 #ShepherdsOfCassini #VölurCares