#logicalfallacy

2026-01-24

I'm no media strategist, but I'm surprised how consistently we let bad-faith actors (or those whose opinions have been shaped by bad-faith actors) define the terms of the conversation across a range of topics.

Consider renewable energy and the need to move away from burning fossil fuels.

"But global warming is a hoax. We're going through a winter storm right now!"

❌ The moment you begin to respond to the "global warming" bit with facts, IPCC reports, and consensus among environmental scientists, you've lost.

Imagine the consensus we could build around ideas if we made an effort to be aware of the things that the bad-faith actors and their followers claim to value and could tap into them.

🤔 "Well, I know that you're afraid about the safety of your children, and I don't think you mean just the physical safety of kids from sexual predators. I'm sure you've been to places with terrible air quality. Would you rather your children grew up breathing fumes from vehicles and coal power plants, or would you rather they breathed clean air?"

Walls of ignorance are torn down brick by brick, and it's up to us to acknowledge the positions people claim, offer empathy, and demonstrate how proposed ideas are actually in alignment with their stated interests.

#ClimateChange #GlobalWarming #LogicalFallacy #DragQueens

2025-11-23

First sip is a delightful mixture of citrus and tropical fruits with a mild bitterness ending it off. The weight of the fruits should not be underestimated, as they absolutely fill the mouth

#Beer #Review #LogicalFallacy #SouthernGrist #Tennessee
bfbcping.com/2025/11/southern-

Rost Glukhovros@techhub.social
2025-10-19

The Free Speech Fallacy occurs when someone uses the concept of free speech to deflect criticism or avoid accountability for their statements. Learn about this logical fallacy with examples:
logical-fallacy.com/articles/f
#logicalfallacy #logic #philosophy #debating #politics

2025-09-17

Phát hiện lỗi logic trong video: Ý tưởng tiện ích trình duyệt giúp nhận diện các ngụy biện (straw man, ad hominem...) khi xem YouTube/Facebook. Click để xem giải thích và kiểm tra sự thật. Hữu ích để chống thông tin sai lệch!

#LogicalFallacy #FallacyDetector #FactCheck #NhanDienNguyBien #KiemTraThongTin

reddit.com/r/opensource/commen

2025-09-17

Ý tưởng: Phát triển công cụ phát hiện lỗi logic trong video mạng xã hội. Tiện ích trình duyệt này sẽ cảnh báo khi gặp ngụy biện (ad hominem, straw man...) và giải thích đơn giản. Hướng đến chống tin giả và nâng cao tư duy phản biện! #AI #LogicalFallacy #TinGiả #TưDuyPhảnBiện

reddit.com/r/SideProject/comme

2025-09-17

Ý tưởng phát hiện lỗi logic trong video: Công cụ mở rộng trình duyệt giúp nhận diện ngụy biện (straw man, ad hominem...) khi xem YouTube/Facebook. Click để xem giải thích và kiểm tra sự thật. Hướng tới phá vỡ buồng vang và chống tin giả! #AI #LogicalFallacy #NgụyBiện #ChốngTinGiả

reddit.com/r/opensource/commen

2025-09-17

Ý tưởng hay từ cộng đồng mã nguồn mở: Một plugin trình duyệt phát hiện lỗi logic (logical fallacy) trong video! Nó sẽ hiển thị biểu tượng nhỏ khi phát hiện các lập luận sai như "ngụy biện rơm" (straw man), tấn công cá nhân (ad hominem), hoặc kêu gọi uy quyền. Áp dụng cho YouTube, X, Facebook qua phụ đề hoặc chuyển giọng nói thành văn bản, click để xem giải thích. Giúp chống thông tin sai lệch từ clip ngắn. Ai quan tâm phát triển?

#LogicalFallacy #Misinformation #AI #OpenSource
#LỗiLogic #Thô

2025-07-14

#fallacy #fallacies #logicalFallacy #logicalFallacies

"When people hear the word bias, many if not most will think of either racial prejudice or news organizations that slant their coverage to favor one political position over another. Present bias, by contrast, is an example of cognitive bias—the collection of faulty ways of thinking that is apparently hardwired into the human brain."

theatlantic.com/magazine/archi

Thor A. Hoplandhopland@snabelen.no
2025-03-19

@AlexanderKingsbury again, you're using the #LogicalFallacy known as an #AdHominem. You're arguing the person, not the merits of the case made. You're trying to use derision and completely ignore context.

You're also misdirecting and picking at straws.

Got anything else, or is it #debatebro on #youtube circa 2007 tactics all the way?

2025-03-12

I just participated in the first W3C Authentic Web Mini Workshop^1 hosted by the Credible Web Community Group^2 (of which I’m a longtime member) and up front I noted that our very discussion itself needed to be careful about its own credibility, extra critical of any technologies discussed or assertions made, and initially identified two flaws to avoid on a meta level, having seen them occur many times in technical or standards discussions:

1. Politician’s Syllogism — "Something must be done about this problem. Here is something, let's do it!"

2. Solutions Looking For Problems — "I am interested in how tech X can solve problem Y"

After some back and forth and arguments in the Zoom chat, I observed participants questioning speakers of arguments rather than the arguments themselves, so I had to identify a third fallacy to avoid:

3. Ad Hominem — while obvious examples are name-calling (which is usually against codes of conduct), less obvious examples (witnessed in the meeting) include questioning a speaker’s education (or lack thereof) like what they have or have not read, or would benefit from reading.

I am blogging these here both as a reminder (should you choose to participate in such discussions), and as a resource to cite in future discussions.

We need to all develop expertise in recognizing these logical and methodological flaws & fallacies, and call them out when we see them, especially when used against others.

We need to promptly prune these flawed methods of discussion, so we can focus on actual productive, relevant, and yes, credible discussions.

#W3C #credweb #credibleWeb #authenticWeb #flaw #fallacy #fallacies #logicalFallacy #logicalFallacies


Glossary

Ad Hominem
  attacking an attribute of the person making an argument rather than the argument itself
  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ad_hominem

Politician's syllogism
  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Politician%27s_syllogism

Solutions Looking For Problems (related: #solutionism, #solutioneering)
  Promoting a technology that either has not identified a real problem for it to solve, or actively pitching a specific technology to any problem that seems related. Wikipedia has no page on this but has two related pages:
  * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_the_instrument
  * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Technological_fix
  Wikipedia does have an essay on this specific to Wikipedia:
  * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Solutions_looking_for_a_problem
  Stack Exchange has a thread on "solution in search of a problem":
  * https://english.stackexchange.com/questions/250320/a-word-that-means-a-solution-in-search-of-a-problem
  Forbes has an illustrative anecdote:  
  * https://www.forbes.com/sites/stephanieburns/2019/05/28/solution-looking-for-a-problem/


References

^1 https://www.w3.org/events/workshops/2025/authentic-web-workshop/
^2 https://credweb.org/ and https://www.w3.org/community/credibility/


Previously in 2019 I participated @misinfocon.com #MisinfoCon:
* https://tantek.com/2019/296/t1/london-misinfocon-discuss-spectrum-recency
* https://tantek.com/2019/296/t2/misinfocon-roundtable-spectrums-misinformation

2025-01-28

The #WashingtonPost opinion columnist Eugene Robinson expresses well the (intended) confusion caused by the #LogicalFallacy called #Equivocation: “Now we know, apparently, that Trump and the MAGA base don’t mean the Tuskegee Airmen when they excoriate DEI. But exactly what do they mean?”

This shows a #CriticalQuestion to ask before believing someone. “What do they mean?”

From: What the Air Force’s Tuskegee Airmen mishap reveals about Trump’s DEI war wapo.st/4hazEH7

2025-01-26

"Very important to vote Republican ... to prevent voting fraud." -- Elon Musk

This is the worst kind of relevance fallacy. NEVER infer towards an unknown. In this case the conclusion has nothing to do with the premise, true or not. It's a clever lie told by a clever liar.

#RM3 #nonBinaryLogic #LogicalFallacy

Nat Oleandernat@partyon.xyz
2025-01-25

White xtian nationalists love the Constitution the same way that they love the Bible: as a convenient old-timey document to unscrupulously comb through for evidence to support whatever they've been told to believe (which is supposedly derived from said document, but really comes from a handful of 20th-century evangelical leaders like James Dobson and Phyllis Schlafly).

#evangelical #exvangelical #whitechristiannationalism #trump #fascism #cognitivedissonace #logicalfallacy

(1/8)

2024-12-22

Just a random note:

"Ad Hominem" is a logical fallacy in which they dismiss the argument by addressing the person not the argument.

Ad Hominem is not calling the person a douchebag while addressing the points of the argument.

Ad Hominem is saying those points should be dismissed because they are a douchebag.

It's thrown around (improperly) often by people who want to basically say "you've lost the argument because you're angry" but what to add elitism on top of entitlement.

Easy test: if you can remove all the insults from the argument and it still makes sense, then it's not Ad Hominem.

#LogicalFallacy #Debate #Arguments #AdHominem

2024-11-22

Randomly reminded of one of my favorite terms: Schrodinger's Douchebag

Definition: someone who is or is not "joking" depending on whether or not people around them agree with the statement

Related: See Poe's Law

#bigots #douchebags #JustJoking #LogicalFallacy #PoesLaw

Blender Dumbass ( J.Y.Amihud )blenderdumbass@mastodon.online
2024-11-17

Judging #research based on who sponsored it is an #Adhominem #logicalfallacy. Yet it seems like not judging it based on who sponsored it is a #fallacyfallacy .

Maybe the best would be to verify and test the ideas in research. But most of us aren't educated enough to even understand them.

How do we solve that without effecting people's #freedom ?

#science #philosophy #education

Jan :rust: :ferris:janriemer@floss.social
2024-10-26

Oh man...I can already see the claims of companies getting so and so more productive and "streamlining" processes thanks to #AI, while it'll turn out that:

Yes, companies will have gotten more productive.

And no, it's not _directly_ because of AI - it's because employees have inadvertently produced a lot of documentation in the hope of "feeding" the AI, while, by documenting things properly, they'll have actually helped humans doing a better job.

🤦

#Fallacy #LogicalFallacy #Causation #LLM

Dan Stands w/Epstein VictimsWastelandWandrr@freeradical.zone
2024-10-23

Nobody observed the billions of years before humanity existed, therefore it never happened!
#LogicalFallacy for you! :blobcatgiggle2:

Client Info

Server: https://mastodon.social
Version: 2025.07
Repository: https://github.com/cyevgeniy/lmst