@
fastfinge What if I told you that just about the whole Fediverse supports quotes, only Mastodon doesn't?
What if I told you that #
MastodonIsNotTheFediverse? What if I told you that I myself am not on Mastodon, although this post of mine has appeared on your timeline?
What if I told you that, in fact, the Fediverse has been around for much longer than Mastodon?
What if I told you that it started in 2008 with something called Laconi.ca, now known as #
GNUsocial (
#^https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GNU_social)
Okay, GNU social doesn't really count as part of today's Fediverse because it doesn't support #
ActivityPub. And okay, it wasn't called the Fediverse back then but the #
FederatedSocialWeb. But still, the whole concept isn't new. It was not invented by Eugen Rochko.
Still, even today's Fediverse is more than Mastodon and older than Mastodon. And just about everything that isn't Mastodon supports quotes while still being fully federated with Mastodon.
But let me elaborate (warning, this post is over 12 times as long as a toot can possibly be):
#
Friendica (
#^https://friendi.ca,
#^https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friendica,
#^https://joinfediverse.wiki/Special:MyLanguage/What_is_Friendica%3F) was launched in July 2010. That was six years before Mastodon. It was created by a guy named
Mike Macgirvin as a decentralised, distributed, federated replacement for Facebook. No, not Twitter. Facebook.
From the very beginning, it had many features which Mastodon users keep demanding today. Including quotes. Again, when Mastodon was launched, Friendica had had these features in daily productive use for six years already.
And yet, people don't use quotes to harass others by "stealing" discussions. This is technically impossible on Friendica due to its architecture which is more like Facebook or a blog or a forum and less like Twitter or Mastodon. Threads aren't stand-alone posts floating around the timelines, loosely tied together by increasing numbers of mentions. Instead, they're start-post-and-comments structures. Replies aren't stand-alone posts. Replies are comments firmly tied to one start post by Friendica's internal structure.
Oh, and Friendica doesn't run on ActivityPub. It has its own internal protocol, #
DFRN. Still, Friendica quickly created an ActivityPub connector and federated with Mastodon, thus becoming part of the Fediverse. Friendica federates with a whole lot of projects and platforms. In fact, there is a growing number of forums mostly frequented by Mastodon users which run on Friendica, such as FediverseNews.
I myself am on #
Hubzilla (
#^https://hubzilla.org,
#^https://joinfediverse.wiki/Special:MyLanguage/What_is_Hubzilla%3F). It started life in 2012, still four years before Mastodon, as a fork of Friendica, created by Friendica's own inventor. In 2011 already, Mike had conceived an even more powerful protocol named #
Zot which comes with features that are outright utterly unimaginable for Mastodon users such as #
NomadicIdentity. Hubzilla even had its first stable release before Mastodon was launched.
And Hubzilla still has almost all the features Friendica has with a whole lot more on top. Again, including quotes. Again, yes, before Mastodon refused to have them. And again, yes, without anyone misusing them for harassment.
And again, it's part of the Fediverse and federated with Mastodon. Otherwise you wouldn't be able to read this.
I should also mention that both Friendica and Hubzilla have technical barriers in the way of publicly quoting private or restricted posts, at least with references/a connection to the quoted post. Hubzilla in particular has access rights control on a level you couldn't possibly imagine in your wildest dreams.
And just about everything else in the Fediverse that's microblogging or macroblogging has official, built-in quote support.
Yes, they're all federated with Mastodon. This means that users of any of these projects, including Friendica and Hubzilla, can read Mastodon posts and quote them in their replies, and these replies, in turn, can be read on Mastodon.
Okay, so the Fediverse has two, three, four... ten projects, and all but Mastodon support quotes, and nowhere are there people demanding the feature be removed due to rampant harassment?
No, these are only the microblogging and macroblogging projects, and only those of the macroblogging projects that aren't primarily for long-form blogging, i.e. that aren't mimicking Medium, that aren't mimicking WordPress, that aren't #
Wordpress itself. Yes, there are WordPress blogs in the Fediverse, federated with Mastodon.
In fact, the Fediverse is even much, much bigger than that (
#^https://fediverse.party/en/miscellaneous/,
#^https://the-federation.info/).
Now go block me for harassing you, for being an ableist swine because I treat blind people equally instead of mollycoddling them wherever possibly, even for being a fascist or just for shattering your worldview into itty bitty pieces. This post of mine stands.
CC @
Patrick, the Linux guy so that you know that the Fediverse is more than Mastodon, too
Also CC @
Ada @
James