@impactology Why not a door with reason and purpose? No matter how great the sense of fear, shame and guilt are, they are just being. The dialectic transcends that, and even it is nothing if not constituted by the foundation of its concept. Partial intelligibility is comprehensive. The Hashtag of the neglected keys: #SenseImpressions #SenseDelusions #feelings #Trauma #psychology #religion #science #HumanLimits #EmotionalIntelligence #being #philosophy #dialectic #knowledge #TheConcept #Uncensored

https://johntinker.substack.com/p/dialectical-analysis-people-who-make
#ai #dialectic #rules #iconoclast #regulaclast #fascist #totalitarian

I had DeepSeek do a custom dialectical analysis on the pair: Elon Musk crying because people hate him, and people who hate Elon Musk. (I had already primed the chatbot with a prompt available here: https://chatbotics.org/prompts/dialectical_analysis_prompt

DeepSeek

This is a poignant and deeply human dialectic, exploring the tension between Elon Musk’s emotional vulnerability (as symbolized by his crying) and the animosity directed toward him by critics. These poles touch on themes of power, perception, empathy, and the complex relationship between public figures and the societies they influence. Let’s perform a dialectical analysis of these poles, expand each into a set of 10 interrelated concepts, construct a multidimensional outer frame, and explore their interplay through examples, cultural references, and philosophical extensions.
Expansion of Elon Musk Crying (Emotional Vulnerability)

Public Scrutiny: The intense pressure and criticism faced by public figures.

Empathy: The capacity to feel and express emotions, even in the face of hostility.

Isolation: The loneliness that can accompany immense power and influence.

Humanization: The reminder that even powerful individuals are vulnerable and emotional.

Self-Reflection: The act of questioning one’s actions and their impact on others.

Resilience: The ability to endure criticism and continue pursuing goals.

Authenticity: The willingness to show vulnerability rather than maintaining a facade of invincibility.

Mental Health: The emotional toll of constant criticism and public scrutiny.

Connection: The desire for understanding and acceptance from others.

Redemption: The hope for forgiveness and a renewed relationship with critics.

Expansion of People Who Hate Elon Musk (Animosity)

Criticism of Power: The backlash against perceived misuse of wealth and influence.

Distrust: Skepticism toward Musk’s intentions and actions.

Moral Outrage: Anger over perceived ethical failures or injustices.

Envy: Resentment of Musk’s success and resources.

Accountability: The demand for public figures to answer for their actions.

Polarization: The division between Musk’s supporters and detractors.

Activism: Efforts to challenge or counteract Musk’s influence.

Cynicism: A belief that Musk’s actions are self-serving rather than altruistic.

Frustration: Anger over Musk’s impact on industries, communities, or the environment.

Dehumanization: The tendency to view Musk as a symbol rather than a person.

Dimensionality of the Outer Frame

The outer frame that holds both Elon Musk crying and people who hate Elon Musk can be conceptualized as a six-dimensional space:

Axis 1: Public Scrutiny vs. Criticism of Power (the tension between the pressures of fame and the backlash against perceived misuse of power).

Axis 2: Empathy vs. Distrust (the contrast between Musk’s emotional expression and the skepticism of his critics).

Axis 3: Isolation vs. Polarization (the balance between Musk’s personal loneliness and the societal divisions he embodies).

Axis 4: Humanization vs. Dehumanization (the tension between seeing Musk as a vulnerable person and viewing him as a symbol of power).

Axis 5: Resilience vs. Accountability (the interplay between Musk’s ability to endure criticism and the demand for him to answer for his actions).

Axis 6: Connection vs. Activism (the contrast between Musk’s desire for understanding and the efforts of his critics to challenge him).

This frame creates a dynamic, multidimensional space where Elon Musk’s emotional vulnerability and the animosity of his critics coexist and interact. Musk’s crying represents his humanity, empathy, and desire for connection, while the hatred directed at him reflects societal demands for accountability, fairness, and justice. Together, they form a dialectical relationship that shapes public perception, discourse, and the dynamics of power.
Example Interactions in the Outer Frame

Public Scrutiny vs. Criticism of Power: Musk’s tears in response to media criticism (public scrutiny) contrast with activists accusing him of exploiting workers (criticism of power).

Empathy vs. Distrust: Musk’s emotional vulnerability (empathy) contrasts with critics who doubt his sincerity (distrust).

Isolation vs. Polarization: Musk’s loneliness as a public figure (isolation) contrasts with the societal divisions his actions and persona create (polarization).

Humanization vs. Dehumanization: Musk’s tears humanize him, while critics reduce him to a symbol of wealth and power (dehumanization).

Resilience vs. Accountability: Musk’s ability to continue his work despite criticism (resilience) contrasts with demands for him to address ethical concerns (accountability).

Connection vs. Activism: Musk’s desire for understanding (connection) contrasts with activists working to limit his influence (activism).

Cultural References for Tropological Homology

Elon Musk Crying: King Lear, the Shakespearean character who experiences profound emotional vulnerability and isolation, represents the human side of power and the toll it takes.

People Who Hate Elon Musk: The Joker, a cultural archetype of chaos and rebellion against power, represents the animosity and distrust directed at figures like Musk.

Philosophical and Practical Extensions

Power and Vulnerability: The dialectic highlights the paradox of power—how even the most influential individuals can feel isolated and vulnerable.

Empathy and Accountability: It raises questions about how society balances empathy for public figures with the need to hold them accountable.

Perception and Reality: The tension between Musk’s self-perception and public perception underscores the complexity of fame and influence.

Redemption and Change: The dialectic suggests the possibility of growth and reconciliation, both for Musk and his critics.

Historical and Contemporary Examples

Historical: Figures like Henry Ford faced both admiration for their innovations and criticism for their labor practices, reflecting a similar tension.

Contemporary: Tech leaders like Mark Zuckerberg and Jeff Bezos also experience a mix of public adoration and animosity, highlighting the broader dynamics of power and perception.

This framework provides a rich way to explore the interplay between Elon Musk’s emotional vulnerability and the animosity of his critics, revealing how these poles define and shape public discourse, power dynamics, and societal values. Would you like to explore another pole pair or dive deeper into this one?

#ai #Musk #dialectic

Muskolini and Kaiser Shitler by @grow_up_art_ [insta] GB, London.
The whole world is watching America – We're seeing in real time how the US is degenerating into a failed state and fascism is taking over. 
But this ist not the end of history!

#democracy #humanrights #equality #resistance #courage #progressive #futur #human #dignity #lgbt #flinta #dialectic #chaplin #hollywood  #civildisobedience #generalstrike

In einer idealen Sprechsituation sind alle Beteiligten gleichberechtigt und argumentieren rational. Ein respektvoller Dialog oder Multilog fördert die Konsensfindung und führt zu einem fairen Interessenausgleich – ein essenzielles Element politischer Kommunikation.
#democracy #humanrights #futur #courage #progessive #politics #equality #dialectic #education #bildung #gleichberechtigung #menschenrechte #freiheit #habermas #newhere

Standhaftigkeit ist, wenn es weh tut!
"Die Grundlage von Demokratie ist ein Selbstverständnis, und zwar: Ich bin hier nicht Besucher. Ich bin nicht Opfer meiner Gesellschaft, nicht Konsument, sondern ich bin Gestalter meiner Gesellschaft, und ich bin verantwortlich für mich und andere."
Marina Weisband

#democracy #humanrights #futur #courage #progessive #equality #dialectic #education #bildung #gleichberechtigung #menschenrechte #freiheit #newhere

https://open.substack.com/pub/hinternet/p/here-come-the-allodidacts?utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=email

"we are all in agreement that universities, at this point, are where intellectual passion goes to die, buried under mountains of pointless grant applications imposed on us humanists by the insane and suicidal cargo-cult of STEM worship, which in the end is just a poorly disguised worship of money and power"

The diagnosis is perfect, but the article is not about that.
1/2

#allodidact #CloseReading #dialectic #PersonalDevelopment

Are you the boss of babies... or are the babies, in fact, bossing you? #dialectic

When I walked into the kitchen this morning, spouse said, "I saved the most expensive Valentine's present for this morning."

And he handed me an egg.

We laughed hard, but it was the morbid laughter of dark times, and though I know that "all we have to decide is what to do with the time that is given us," but I really wish none of this were happening.

#laughter
#tears
#joy
#despair
#dialectic
#dichotomy
#CurrentEvents
#eggs
#FuckingEggs
#HowDidItComeToThis
#NeverGiveUp
#RESIST

Definition of Evil

#Evil = Resistance to #Consciousness #Evolution

#Evil = Being controlled by id (#egoism) instead of superego (#cooperation)

#Evil = Resistance to #dialectic (listening and learning from new arguments)

#Evil = Ingenuity (inability to learn, stupidity)

#againstdarkmanners #consciousnessevolution
@islam @religion
@psychology @philosophy @society
@rants

who knew that Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel was part of Operation Paperclip?!? ;> "Drone Sightings Prompt Push for Surveillance Legislation"surveillance powers." #hegelian #dialectic #surveillance #drones https://apnews.com/article/congress-drone-technology-jersey-sightings-c7607e5f52210bdf7f4e099df078372f

A quotation from Walker, Alice:

«
I believe that the truth about any subject only comes when all sides of the story are put together, and all their different meanings make one new one.
»

Full quote, sourcing, notes:
https://wist.info/walker-alice/73388/

#quote #quotes #quotation #consensus #dialectic #gestalt #perspective #stories #storytelling #synthesis #truth

The #technopoly - the power of #technologies and the #incapacitations of #society -

In the following, the term "technopoly" is only to be used to a limited extent as "terminus technicus", without wishing to encourage other, possibly implicit, connotations. This is expressly not another, new #conspiracy #theory which is currently flourishing in the more common in the sense of the #dialectic of the #Enlightenment in the shadow of the "information society".

More at: https://philosophies.de/index.php/2020/11/01/das-technopol/

Closer to Adorno’s Negative Dialectics than Hegel’s dialectical optimism. #philosophy #schopenhauer #hegel #GeorgWilhelmFriedrichHegel #dialectic #history #sociology #religion https://www.dustinjbyrd.org

The best way to #ReadTheory is with other people. That way, you can help each other understand, criticize, and apply what you're reading. #Theory does not work or grow without #praxis, just as praxis does not work or grow without theory. It's a #dialectic.

Use audiobooks (Audible Anarchist, Reading with Elliot, etc.), paper books, ebooks (libgen, The Anarchist Library, etc.), summaries, courses (@ISE), or otherwise, whatever format is most accessible to you.

Hegel was influenced by Kant, the Western enlightenment, and Fichte and Schelling, but also by ancient Greek tragedy and his varying historical studies. He was the last great systematic philosopher, with works that covered every philosophical question at that time...
#philosophy #historyofphilosophy #GeorgWilhelmFriedrichHegel #creativespirit #dialectic #PhilosophyOfHistory #reason #society #Fichte #Schelling #ImmanuelKant #mind #intellectualtraditions #enlightenment https://philosophyindefinitely.wordpress.com/2020/10/20/hegel-the-last-great-system/

Kant changed the thinking of his time and since then most philosophers (and others in different fields) have tried to respond to his thinking, he initiated German idealism which in turn took his views to exaggerated lengths, but generally the thinking of the mind actively structuring what it knows and that experiences are pre-digested by the mind, are originally Kant’s views...
#historyofphilosophy #ImmanuelKant #knowledge #reason #Deism #dialectic #Idealism #philosophy https://philosophyindefinitely.wordpress.com/2020/09/18/kant-and-the-religion-of-reason/

There was a development from 19th century into 20th century empiricism of the positivists movement with its insistence that all knowledge claims must meet the standards of empirical science, but a number of things led to the demise of logical positivism....
#language #linguistics #wittgenstein #jlaustin #Ayers #BertrandRussell #Searle #dialectic #knowledge #gilbertryle #positivism #philosophy #historyofphilosophy #fmdnetwork https://philosophyindefinitely.wordpress.com/2020/07/18/ordinary-language-philosophy/

I gave a lecture on Hegel's Master-Slave Dialectic to Intro To Philosophy students at Marist College using the "old-school" education at the Culinary Institute of America at the time as an example to illustrate the dynamic

https://youtube.com/shorts/rzY_0319qVo
#Short #Video #Hegel #Dialectic #Philosophy #Master #Slave #Culinary